Royalty payments to associated enterprises deemed arm's length despite TPO restrictions; CCD interest deductible as debt

ITAT Bangalore held that the assessee's royalty payment to associated enterprises was at arm's length, rejecting TPO's 1% restriction based on prior tribunal decisions in the assessee's own case. Regarding CCDs, the tribunal ruled that until conversion, CCDs should be treated as debt for income tax purposes, allowing interest deduction despite RBI's equity classification for FDI policy. The interest rate benchmarking using average rupee cost compared to SBI prime lending rate was accepted. The TDS matter was remanded to AO for examination of the assessee's credit entitlement.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. TP adjustment of Rs. 51,76,98,493/- in respect of payment of royalty.
2. TP adjustment of Rs. 326,04,19,415/- in respect of payment of interest on CCDs, premium expenditure on repayment of CCDs, and interest on RDBs.
3. Short credit of tax deducted at source.

Summary:

1. TP Adjustment of Rs. 51,76,98,493/- (Payment of Royalty):
The Tribunal addressed the issue of TP adjustment of Rs. 51,76,98,493/- for royalty payment by the assessee to its AE. The assessee argued that this issue had been previously decided in its favor for earlier assessment years, where the payment of royalty was held to be at arm's length. The Tribunal noted that the assessee had benchmarked the transaction using the Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP) method and the Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM), both concluding the transaction to be at arm's length. However, the TPO had restricted the ALP transaction to 1%, relying on earlier assessment orders. The Tribunal found that in earlier years, the payment of royalty at 4% was accepted as at arm's length. Therefore, following the precedent, the Tribunal held that the payment of royalty by the assessee for the current year should also be treated as at arm's length and allowed the grounds in favor of the assessee.

2. TP Adjustment of Rs. 326,04,19,415/- (Interest on CCDs, Premium Expenditure on Repayment of CCDs, and Interest on RDBs):
The assessee contested the TP adjustment of Rs. 326,04,19,415/- related to interest on CCDs, premium expenditure on repayment of CCDs, and interest on RDBs. The TPO had recharacterized CCDs as equity and held the payments as non-interest in nature, determining the arm's length price of interest payment on CCDs to be NIL. The DRP upheld the TPO's order. The assessee argued that the TPO and DRP erred in treating CCDs as equity and cited previous Tribunal decisions, including its own case, where CCDs were considered debt until conversion. The Tribunal, referencing its earlier decisions and the case of CAE Flight Training (India) Pvt. Ltd., reiterated that CCDs are debt until conversion and recharacterization is impermissible. The Tribunal restored the matter to the files of the AO/TPO to pass fresh orders, complying with the Tribunal's direction for earlier assessment years. Thus, the grounds were partly allowed for statistical purposes.

3. Short Credit of Tax Deducted at Source:
The assessee claimed a short credit of TDS amounting to Rs. 6,39,26,468/-, whereas the AO had granted credit for Rs. 6,33,49,371/-. The Tribunal directed the AO to examine the entitlement of the entire credit claimed by the assessee and pass an order after providing a reasonable opportunity of being heard. Consequently, this ground was allowed for statistical purposes.

Conclusion:
The appeal filed by the assessee was partly allowed, with specific directions for fresh orders on TP adjustments and examination of TDS credit.

---