Court quashes Assessment Order due to unfair time frame, emphasizes natural justice principles

The court quashed the Assessment Order dated 25/05/2021 due to the unreasonable time frame given during the lockdown and holidays, which violated the principles of natural justice. The matter was remanded for fresh consideration, emphasizing the importance of natural justice. The petitioner was directed to respond to the notice within two weeks, and the Assessing Officer was instructed to consider the submissions and documents, granting a personal hearing before passing a new order. The court clarified no observations were made on the merits of the case and excluded a specific period for calculating the time limit for passing a re-Assessment Order.

---

---

Issues:
Impugning Assessment Order under Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 for AY 2018-19 due to insufficient time granted for submission of documents during lockdown.

Analysis:
1. The petitioner challenged the Assessment Order dated 25/05/2021, which computed the total income at Rs. 114,57,33,424/-, contrary to the declared total income of Rs. Nil for AY 2018-19. The petitioner received a notice under Section 142(1) on 20/05/2021, with a short deadline of 25/05/2021 for submission of various details. The lockdown in Mumbai and weekend holidays limited the petitioner's ability to compile the extensive documentation requested, which would have taken at least a month and exceeded 1000 pages. Despite this, the respondents proceeded with the Assessment Order, adding a significant amount to the petitioner's total income.

2. The respondents filed an Affidavit-in-Reply, which contained errors acknowledged by the court. The court allowed the withdrawal of the affidavit but denied the liberty to file a fresh one, as it would not impact the allegations in the petition. Upon reviewing the petition, documents, and Assessment Order, the court noted the unreasonable time frame given during the lockdown and holidays, which violated the principles of natural justice. Consequently, the court quashed the Assessment Order dated 25/05/2021 and remanded the matter for fresh consideration, emphasizing the importance of natural justice.

3. The court directed the petitioner to respond to the notice issued on 20/05/2021 within two weeks. The Assessing Officer was instructed to consider the petitioner's submissions and documents, granting a personal hearing before passing a new order in accordance with the law. The court clarified that no observations were made on the merits of the case and excluded the period between 25/05/2021 and the current date for calculating the time limit for passing a re-Assessment Order. Finally, the petition was disposed of with no order as to costs, ensuring fairness and procedural compliance in the assessment process.

---