Pre-existing dispute under insolvency law must be pending or real; absent that, Section 9 admission can proceed.

An operational creditor's Section 9 application under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code was held maintainable because no suit, arbitration, or other real pre-existing dispute was pending on the date of the demand notice or filing. The Tribunal found that the corporate debtor's challenge to the arbitral award had already been dismissed in default and was not pending, so the dispute objection did not bar admission. It also recorded that the statutory conditions for admission were satisfied and that no disciplinary proceeding was pending against the proposed insolvency professional. The corporate debtor was admitted into Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process, moratorium was declared, and an Interim Resolution Professional was appointed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the application under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 was maintainable when the challenge to the arbitral award was not pending on the date of demand notice and filing of the application, and whether any pre-existing dispute barred admission of the insolvency petition.

Analysis: The operational creditor had obtained an arbitral award, which was confirmed by the District Court. The corporate debtor's appeal against the award had been dismissed in default and, on the material before the Tribunal, was not pending when the demand notice was issued or when the Section 9 application was filed. The Tribunal applied the principle that an operational debt is treated as disputed only where a suit or arbitration proceeding concerning the debt is actually pending or otherwise constitutes a real pre-existing dispute. Since no such pending proceeding existed on the relevant date, the objection based on dispute did not survive. The Tribunal also noted that the conditions for admission under Section 9 were satisfied and that no disciplinary proceeding was pending against the proposed insolvency professional.

Conclusion: The Section 9 application was maintainable and the corporate debtor was admitted into Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process, with moratorium declared and an Interim Resolution Professional appointed.

---