Monetary-limit exception for bogus penny-stock gains allowed recall of a low-tax-effect dismissal and restored the appeal.

A later CBDT circular and office memorandum carved out an exception from the monetary-limit policy for cases involving bogus long-term capital gains through penny stocks. The Tribunal held that, because the Revenue's appeal fell within that exceptional category, the earlier dismissal based solely on low tax effect could not stand. The miscellaneous application was therefore allowed, the prior order was recalled, and the appeal was restored for hearing on merits. The operative principle is that a subsequent instruction expressly excluding a class of cases from the monetary-limit regime can justify reopening an appeal earlier dismissed only for low tax effect.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Revenue's miscellaneous application seeking recall of the earlier order dismissing its appeal on the ground of low tax effect was liable to be allowed in view of the CBDT's later circular and office memorandum carving out an exception for cases involving bogus long-term capital gains through penny stocks.

Analysis: The Tribunal noted that the earlier dismissal of the appeal had been based on the monetary limits prescribed by the CBDT circulars. On examining the later circular and office memorandum, it found that cases involving bogus long-term capital gains through penny stocks were expressly placed in the exceptional category to the monetary limit policy. Since the present appeal fell within that category, the earlier order could not stand.

Conclusion: The miscellaneous application was allowed and the earlier order was recalled, with the appeal directed to be listed for hearing on merits.

Final Conclusion: The Tribunal reopened the Revenue's appeal and restored it for regular adjudication, holding that the monetary-limit restriction did not apply to the case.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a later CBDT instruction expressly excludes a class of cases from the monetary-limit regime, an appeal earlier dismissed solely for low tax effect may be recalled and restored for hearing on merits.

---