Chapter 86 classification denied for unassembled railway parts requiring substantial further manufacturing before completion.

Parts and sub-parts supplied in unassembled condition from one unit to another were not treated as complete or finished railway goods for classification under Chapter 86 because the receiving unit was to carry out substantial assembly, welding, painting, testing, inspection and addition of components. Rule 2(a) of the General Rules for the Interpretation of the Harmonized System did not apply, as the goods were not merely presented unassembled but required further manufacturing activity before becoming the finished article. The concessional GST rate linked to Chapter 86 was therefore unavailable, and the goods were liable to tax under the applicable chapters for each item.

---

---

Issues: Whether the goods supplied from the Pathredi unit to the Chennai unit, being parts and sub-parts sent in unassembled condition for further assembly and processing, were classifiable under Chapter 86 of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 so as to attract the concessional GST rate applicable to railway goods.

Analysis: The goods dispatched from Pathredi were found to be parts and sub-parts rather than complete sub-assemblies. The Chennai unit was to undertake substantial operations including assembly, welding, painting, testing, inspection, and addition of components procured from other suppliers. On this factual basis, the supply was not treated as merely unassembled presentation of a complete or finished article. The interpretative guidance under Rule 2(a) of the General Rules for the Interpretation of the Harmonized System, which treats complete or finished articles presented unassembled or disassembled as classifiable with the assembled article, was held inapplicable because the Chennai process involved further assembly and manufacturing activity. The circular clarifying that only goods classifiable under Chapter 86 supplied to Railways attract the concessional rate was also applied.

Conclusion: The goods supplied from the Pathredi unit to the Chennai unit could not be classified under Chapter 86 and were liable to the general applicable rate according to the classification of each item in its respective chapter.

---