2019 (2) TMI 1760 - HC - Indian Laws

Delhi High Court Orders Provision of Verification Report to Petitioners, Dismisses Writ Petitions

NOBEL NC CO. LTD., NITRO CHEMICAL INDUSTRY LIMITED Versus UNION OF INDIA. & ORS.

The Delhi High Court considered a case involving a Verification Report by the Designated Authority (DA) in response to complaints. The court confirmed the ... Permission for withdrawal of appeal - Scope of verification - the records considered by the Designated Authority (DA) were produced in Court, the records include the Verification Report carried out by the DA - HELD THAT:- Petition dismissed as withdrawn. Issues involved:Verification Report not part of the record, confidentiality concerns, DA's failure to address submissions.Analysis:The judgment delivered by the Delhi High Court involved the consideration of a Verification Report by the Designated Authority (DA) in response to complaints raised by the petitioners. The petitioners contended that the verification was not part of the record. However, the court noted that the exporter's Verification Report, including details of the verification conducted at the petitioners' premises, was indeed part of the record presented in court. The DA assured that a copy of the Verification Report would be provided to the petitioners, addressing the initial concern raised.Furthermore, the petitioners, represented by learned senior counsel, highlighted additional grounds for concern, including issues related to confidentiality and the DA's failure to address their submissions adequately. It was decided that the respondents would furnish a copy of the Verification Report to the petitioners' counsel within a week. The petitioners were granted the opportunity to make representations to the Central Government to seek intervention and appropriate action based on their concerns, ensuring compliance with the law.In light of these developments and the assurance of providing the Verification Report, the learned senior counsel for the petitioners sought permission to withdraw the petitions. The court granted this request, leading to the dismissal of the writ petitions as withdrawn, along with any pending applications. This comprehensive analysis of the judgment showcases the court's consideration of the issues raised by the petitioners, the actions taken by the DA and respondents to address those concerns, and the final decision to allow the withdrawal of the petitions in light of the provided assurances and opportunities for further representation.