Court upholds notice validity despite typographical error under Income Tax Act, assessee's defense opportunity preserved

The High Court dismissed the argument that no valid notice was issued under section 271AAB of the Income Tax Act, 1961, despite a typographical error in the notice initially labeled under section 271AAA. The Court emphasized that the correction occurred before penalty proceedings advanced, allowing the assessee a full opportunity to defend. However, the Court expressed intent to further examine the lack of sanction for initiating penalty proceedings, scheduling the matter for final disposal to delve into this crucial issue.

---

---

Issues involved: Challenge to penalty imposed under section 271AAB of the Income Tax Act, 1961 - Incorrect factual assertion by the Tribunal regarding notice issuance under section 271AAB - Lack of sanction for initiation of penalty proceedings.

Analysis:

1. The appellant-assessee challenged the penalty imposed by the Assessing Officer under section 271AAB of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The first contention raised was that the Tribunal incorrectly assumed a separate notice under section 271AAB was issued, whereas the Assessing Officer had initially issued a notice under section 271AAA, later corrected to 271AAB through a corrigendum. The High Court opined that the correction of the statutory provision was merely a typographical error and did not vitiate the proceedings as the correction occurred before the penalty proceedings advanced, and the assessee was given a full opportunity to defend. Therefore, the argument that no valid notice was issued was dismissed by the Court.

2. The second contention raised by the appellant was regarding the lack of sanction for initiating penalty proceedings as required by law. The High Court expressed inclination to examine this aspect, focusing on whether the initial notice, albeit erroneously labeled under section 271AAA, was preceded by the necessary sanction. This issue was deemed crucial for further inquiry by the Court.

3. The High Court scheduled the matter for final disposal on 26.11.2018, indicating that a detailed examination of the sanction for initiating penalty proceedings would be undertaken. This step underscored the Court's intent to delve deeper into the aspect of prior sanction, signaling a thorough analysis of this critical issue in the upcoming proceedings.

---