Liaison office and permanent establishment rules: absence of core business activity defeats attribution, while section 234B interest is not leviable.

A liaison office does not constitute a fixed place permanent establishment in India unless the Revenue proves with cogent material that it performs core business functions, concludes contracts, or otherwise carries on income-earning activity in India; where the record shows only liaison functions and head office handling of orders and contract execution, permanent establishment is not established. Once no permanent establishment exists, attribution of fees for technical services to that establishment cannot stand and the matter may require fresh examination of treaty-based taxation and applicable rates on the correct legal footing. Interest under section 234B is not leviable in a non-resident taxation context where tax is deductible at source.

---

---

Issues: (i) whether the liaison office constituted a fixed place permanent establishment in India; (ii) whether fees for technical services were effectively connected with the alleged permanent establishment so as to warrant attribution and require fresh adjudication; (iii) whether interest under section 234B of the Income-tax Act, 1961 was leviable.

Issue (i): whether the liaison office constituted a fixed place permanent establishment in India.

Analysis: The power of attorney and RBI permission showed that the liaison office was permitted only to carry out liaison work and formal office functions. The record did not establish that the office was authorized to conduct core business operations, conclude contracts, or carry on income-earning activity in India. The Revenue also did not rebut the assessee's documentary evidence showing that purchase orders, quotations, invoices, and contract execution were handled by the head office outside India. The finding that the liaison office was carrying on the assessee's business, or that false declarations had been made to the RBI, was not supported by material on record.

Conclusion: The assessee did not have a fixed place permanent establishment in India.

Issue (ii): whether fees for technical services were effectively connected with the alleged permanent establishment so as to warrant attribution and require fresh adjudication.

Analysis: Once the absence of a permanent establishment was held in favour of the assessee, the finding that the fees for technical services were attributable to such establishment could not survive. At the same time, the assessee accepted taxability of the fees for technical services and sought consideration of the applicable treaty rate and related questions in accordance with law. The issue was therefore required to be examined afresh by the Assessing Officer on the basis of the correct legal position, including the assessee's claim under the treaty framework.

Conclusion: The attribution finding was vacated and the issue of taxation of fees for technical services was remanded for de novo adjudication.

Issue (iii): whether interest under section 234B of the Income-tax Act, 1961 was leviable.

Analysis: The levy under sections 234A and 234C was not pursued, while the levy under section 234B was challenged. The applicable jurisdictional precedent held that such interest was not chargeable in the circumstances of the case involving non-resident taxation where tax was deductible at source.

Conclusion: Interest under section 234B was not leviable.

Final Conclusion: The assessee succeeded on the existence of permanent establishment and on interest under section 234B, while the issue relating to fees for technical services was sent back for fresh adjudication, resulting in only a partial allowance of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi: A liaison office does not constitute a fixed place permanent establishment unless the Revenue establishes, by cogent material, that it performs core business functions or concludes contracts in India; treaty-based attribution and consequential tax computations cannot rest on assumptions once such establishment is not proved.

---