Input tax credit documents may be produced before the assessing authority at appeal stage for verification and fresh reassessment.

Where declaration forms, tax invoices and Forms VAT C-4 were not produced earlier for sufficient cause, they could be filed before the assessing authority even at the appellate stage. The Court applied its prior binding decisions and directed that the documents be verified, after which input tax credit and the dealer's tax liability must be re-examined and a fresh order passed in accordance with law. The appeal was disposed of to that extent, with the matter remitted for fresh adjudication on production and verification of the relevant records.

---

---

Issues: Whether the dealer could produce declaration forms, tax invoices and Forms VAT C-4 at the appellate stage for consideration of input tax credit and consequential re-determination of liability.

Analysis: The dispute was treated as already concluded by prior binding decisions of the same Court, which held that such forms and invoices could be produced before the assessing authority. The assessing authority was required to verify the documents and pass a fresh order in accordance with law.

Conclusion: The dealer was permitted to produce the requisite forms and invoices before the assessing authority for verification and fresh adjudication; the challenge was therefore accepted to that extent.

Final Conclusion: The appeal was disposed of in terms consistent with the earlier decisions, with the matter to be examined afresh by the assessing authority on production of the documents.

Ratio Decidendi: Where declaration forms and tax invoices are not furnished earlier for sufficient cause, they may be produced before the assessing authority even at the appellate stage, and the tax liability must then be re-examined on verification of those documents.

---