Real income principle governs NPA interest taxation for co-operative banks under RBI prudential norms.

For a co-operative bank governed by RBI prudential norms, interest on non-performing assets and sticky advances is recognised only when it constitutes real income and is actually received or otherwise credited in the relevant sense. The article notes that coordinate-bench and High Court-supported decisions have applied this principle to exclude such interest from accrual-based taxation, while authorities dealing with non-banking financial companies or provision for NPAs were distinguished as not governing income recognition. Accordingly, the treatment of NPA interest depends on the applicable real income doctrine and prudential framework, rather than on a notional accrual basis.

---

---

Issues: Whether interest receivable on non-performing assets and sticky loans of a co-operative bank was taxable on accrual basis, or whether it could be excluded from income in view of the statutory and regulatory regime governing recognition of such interest.

Analysis: The assessee, being a co-operative bank, was held to be covered by the line of decisions applying the principle that interest on sticky advances or NPAs does not accrue as real income until receipt or credit in the relevant sense. The Tribunal followed its earlier decisions on identical facts and distinguished authorities relied on by the Revenue, including cases dealing with non-banking financial companies and provision for NPAs rather than income recognition. The reasoning proceeded on the basis that the RBI prudential norms and the accepted real income principle govern recognition of such interest, and that the contrary view urged by the Revenue did not displace the existing coordinate-bench and High Court-supported view.

Conclusion: The interest on NPA or sticky loans was not assessable on accrual basis in the hands of the assessee bank, and the deletion of the addition was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: For a co-operative bank governed by RBI prudential norms, interest on NPAs or sticky advances is taxable only when it is recognised as real income in the manner accepted by the applicable legal framework, and not merely on a notional accrual basis.

---