Mandatory securities disclosures remain enforceable despite inadvertence or mitigating factors; reduced penalty sustained for late compliance.

Mandatory disclosure obligations under the securities regulations were triggered once share sales crossed the relevant threshold, and belated disclosure after a show-cause notice did not cure the default. Inadvertence, claimed ignorance, absence of alleged gain, availability of trade details on the stock exchange website, and personal circumstances such as blindness were treated only as mitigating factors, not as grounds to erase statutory non-compliance. A penalty already fixed well below the statutory maximum was not interfered with, as no disproportionality or illegality was shown. The disclosure default and consequent penalty were sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether the penalty imposed for failure to make the required disclosures under the securities regulations was liable to be set aside or reduced on the ground that the breach was inadvertent, technical, belatedly cured, or otherwise deserving of leniency.

Analysis: The disclosure requirements under the insider trading and takeover regulations were mandatory once the appellant's sale of shares crossed the relevant threshold. The disclosures were admittedly made only after issuance of the show-cause notice, reflecting a substantial delay. The penalty imposed was far below the maximum penalty that could have been levied under the governing provision. The availability of transaction details on the stock exchange website, absence of alleged gain, claimed ignorance, and the appellant's blindness were treated as mitigating circumstances, but not as grounds to extinguish the statutory obligation or the penal consequence for non-compliance.

Conclusion: The challenge to the penalty failed, and the penalty was upheld against the appellant.

Final Conclusion: The appeal was dismissed, with the statutory disclosure defaults and the resulting penalty being sustained.

Ratio Decidendi: A mandatory disclosure obligation under the securities regulations remains enforceable despite inadvertence, absence of gain, or other mitigating circumstances, and a reduced penalty within statutory limits will not be interfered with absent disproportionality or illegality.

---