Appellant ordered to pre-deposit Rupees 15 Lakhs for denied Cenvat credit on service tax for Fly Ash.

The Tribunal directed the appellant, engaged in cement manufacturing, to make a pre-deposit of Rupees Fifteen Lakhs within eight weeks for the denial of Cenvat credit on service tax paid for the procurement and movement of Fly ash. Failure to comply would result in the waiver of the balance amount of tax, interest, and penalty, with a stay on recovery until the appeal's final disposal, emphasizing the importance of proving ownership of the Fly Ash Handling System in the Thermal Power Station for eligibility of Cenvat credit.

---

---

Issues: Denial of Cenvat credit for service tax paid on procurement and movement of Fly ash used in cement manufacturing.

Analysis:
1. The appellant, engaged in cement manufacturing, was denied Cenvat credit by the Commissioner for service tax paid on the procurement and movement of Fly ash to service providers. The Commissioner contended that the services provided by contractors for collecting Dry Fly Ash from a Thermal Power Station were not related to the manufacturing activity of cement.

2. The appellant argued that the services rendered by the contractors for collecting Fly Ash were essential inputs used in the manufacturing process of cement, thus falling under the definition of Input Services Credit as per Rule 2(l) of the CENVAT Credit Rules. The appellant cited various decisions to support their claim, emphasizing the relevance of Fly Ash in cement production.

3. The Revenue's representative countered the appellant's argument by stating that there was no evidence to prove ownership of the Fly Ash Handling System in the Thermal Power Station by the appellant. The representative highlighted that the cases cited by the appellant involved situations where the property belonged to the assessee, which was not the case in the present scenario.

4. Upon reviewing the agreement presented by the appellant's counsel, the Tribunal noted ambiguity regarding ownership of the Fly Ash Handling System in the Thermal Power Station. The Tribunal found that the case laws cited by the appellant were not directly applicable to the current circumstances, as ownership of the system was a crucial factor in determining eligibility for Cenvat credit.

5. Consequently, the Tribunal directed the appellant to make a pre-deposit of Rupees Fifteen Lakhs within eight weeks, pending further proceedings. The pre-deposit would allow for the waiver of the balance amount of tax, interest, and penalty, with a stay on recovery until the appeal's final disposal. The appellant was instructed to report compliance by a specified date to ensure procedural adherence.

---