Prima facie merits and financial hardship must guide stay conditions in tax appeals to avoid rendering the appeal ineffective.

In stay applications pending tax appeals, interim protection must be by assessing both prima facie merits and the applicant's financial hardship; a mechanical pre-deposit condition is impermissible because it may make the appeal ineffective. The court modified the Tribunal's stay order, granting complete stay in some assessments on furnishing security and partial stay in others with limited deposit and security, so that the appeal remained viable while protecting revenue interests.

---

---

Issues: Whether, in pending revisions arising from stay applications in tax appeals, the appellate authority was required to consider the prima facie merits of the case and the revisionist's financial stringency while determining the extent of pre-deposit or stay of disputed tax.

Analysis: In matters relating to interim protection during the pendency of a statutory appeal, the relevant considerations include both the prima facie merit of the challenge and the financial condition of the applicant. An order dealing with stay cannot be passed mechanically, and the discretion must be exercised judicially after taking into account undue hardship and the effect that an excessive deposit condition may have on the efficacy of the appeal. Applying those principles to the facts, the Tribunal's order required modification. For some assessments, complete stay was warranted on furnishing security to the satisfaction of the assessing authority. For the remaining assessments, a substantial stay with a limited deposit and security was considered appropriate.

Conclusion: The revisions were partly allowed and the Tribunal's stay order was modified by granting fuller interim protection in some matters and partial stay in the others, subject to deposit and security conditions.

Ratio Decidendi: While deciding stay or waiver-cum-stay applications in tax appeals, the authority must judicially consider both the prima facie merits and the applicant's financial hardship, so that the appeal is not rendered illusory by an onerous pre-deposit condition.

---