Warranty service materials and service tax base: Tribunal granted pre-deposit waiver and stayed recovery pending appeal.

In a dispute over service tax on materials used during warranty service, the Tribunal considered whether the value of parts supplied free of charge could be excluded from the tax base under the exemption notification and whether those materials were sold to the service recipient. It noted that the record did not show any specific instance of Cenvat credit being taken on the materials used, and that the lower proceedings had not clearly segregated any consumable component from the parts issue. On that basis, and in view of similar relief granted in comparable matters, interim protection was granted: waiver of pre-deposit was allowed and recovery of the disputed dues was stayed pending appeal.

---

---

Issues: Whether the applicant was entitled to waiver of pre-deposit and stay of recovery pending appeal in relation to service tax demand on materials used during warranty service.

Analysis: The dispute centered on whether the value of parts or materials supplied during free warranty service could be excluded from the service tax base under the exemption notification, and whether the materials were sold to the service recipient. The record also did not show any specific instance of Cenvat credit having been taken on the materials used. On the material placed, the controversy appeared to relate primarily to parts rather than consumables, and the lower proceedings had not segregated any consumable component with clarity. In these circumstances, and noting that similar relief had been granted in comparable matters, the Tribunal found it appropriate to grant interim protection.

Conclusion: Waiver of pre-deposit was granted and recovery of the disputed dues was stayed during the pendency of the appeal.

---