Capital computation under surtax law: proposed dividend, long-term institutional borrowings, and bonus share capitalisation were treated by statutory terms.

For capital computation under the Second Schedule to the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, a proposed dividend approved with the annual accounts was required to be deducted from general reserve, so the reserve was reduced accordingly. Borrowings from the specified financial institution remained includible where the borrowing agreement stipulated repayment over not less than seven years, and actual early repayment did not alter that statutory character. For exclusion from capital based on book-asset increase, the decisive factor was a demonstrable rise in the value of book assets; in the absence of revaluation or similar increase, mere transfer of reserves and capitalisation for bonus shares did not trigger the exclusion.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether proposed dividend recommended by the directors was to be deducted from general reserve for computation of capital under the Second Schedule to the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964. (ii) Whether borrowings from the Industrial Credit and Investment Corporation of India under an agreement providing repayment over not less than seven years remained includible in capital computation despite earlier actual repayment. (iii) Whether, for computation of capital, the difference between depreciation actually allowed and depreciation debited in the books could be excluded from the capital base for the assessment years in question, including the effect of capitalisation and issue of bonus shares.

Issue (i): Whether proposed dividend recommended by the directors was to be deducted from general reserve for computation of capital under the Second Schedule to the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964.

Analysis: The relevant consideration was whether the dividend recommendation related to the same accounting year and was approved along with the accounts in the annual general meeting. The timing of the recommendation, whether made on the date of finalisation of accounts or shortly thereafter, was held to be immaterial where the recommendation and accounts for the year were approved together. The reserve was therefore required to be reduced by the amount of the proposed dividend.

Conclusion: The issue was decided against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue.

Issue (ii): Whether borrowings from the Industrial Credit and Investment Corporation of India under an agreement providing repayment over not less than seven years remained includible in capital computation despite earlier actual repayment.

Analysis: The governing provision required only that the money be borrowed from the specified institution and that the borrowing agreement provide for repayment during a period of not less than seven years. The actual fact of repayment within seven years was held to be irrelevant, because the statutory condition turns on the terms of the borrowing agreement, not on subsequent conduct.

Conclusion: The issue was decided in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue.

Issue (iii): Whether the difference between depreciation actually allowed and depreciation debited in the books could be excluded from the capital base, including the effect of capitalisation and issue of bonus shares.

Analysis: For the earlier assessment year, the question was treated as already concluded against the assessee. For the later assessment years, the decisive inquiry was whether there had been any increase in the value of book assets by revaluation or otherwise so as to attract the exclusion relating to paid-up share capital created by an increase in book assets. In the absence of any such increase in book asset valuation, the mere transfer of amounts from reserves and their subsequent capitalisation for issue of bonus shares did not attract the exclusion.

Conclusion: The issue was decided against the assessee for the earlier assessment year and in favour of the assessee for the later assessment years.

Final Conclusion: The reference was answered on a mixed basis, with one question decided for the Revenue, one for the assessee, and the capital-computation question partly against the assessee and partly in its favour.

Ratio Decidendi: For capital computation under the Second Schedule, dividend recommendations approved with the annual accounts reduce reserves, borrowings qualify if the agreement stipulates repayment over not less than seven years regardless of early repayment, and exclusion linked to paid-up capital created by increased book asset values applies only where there is a demonstrable increase in the value of book assets.

---