Marketability test for goods bars sales tax on film processing treated as customer-specific service

Exposed photographic film rolls and negatives were held not to be goods because, before development, they had no independent utility and were not marketable. On that basis, processing and development of the films did not amount to a works contract, as the statutory definition applied only where existing goods were processed with transfer of property in goods involved in execution of the contract. The chemicals used in development did not create a taxable sale. The activity was characterised as a customer-specific service based on skill and expertise, so no sales tax was leviable on that footing.

---

---

Issues: Whether exposed photographic film rolls and negatives were "goods" within the meaning of the Assam General Sales Tax Act, 1993, and whether their development and processing constituted a works contract or taxable sale.

Analysis: The statutory scheme treated a works contract as involving processing or treating of goods and a sale as including transfer of property in goods involved in execution of such a contract. The Court applied the settled test that an item must have utility and be marketable to qualify as goods. Exposed film rolls and negatives, before development, had no independent utility and were not marketable. As they were not goods, the processing of them could not fall within the works contract definition. The chemicals used in the process also did not give rise to a taxable sale, since the charging provisions applied only where there was a transfer of property in goods involved in a works contract. The processing of photographs was therefore a customer-specific service based on skill and expertise, not a works contract.

Conclusion: Exposed photographic film rolls and negatives were not goods, the processing activity was not a works contract, and no sales tax was leviable on that basis.

Final Conclusion: The appeals succeeded and the assessment demands and the judgment under challenge were set aside.

Ratio Decidendi: An item is goods for sales tax purposes only if it has utility and is marketable, and a processing activity is a works contract only when it involves existing goods in which property is transferred during execution of the contract.

---