Strict construction of exemption clauses denies relief for unrelated diversified products outside the original industrial unit's covered output

An exemption notification must be strictly construed at the eligibility stage, and diversification into unrelated goods does not satisfy a clause confined to additional principal products, by-products, waste products or connected incidental items of the original industrial unit. On the facts discussed, DVD boxes, television sets and sanitary napkins were not treated as covered products under Clause 5 because they were unrelated to the unit's principal output. The exemption benefit was therefore unavailable, and the refusal to extend sales tax exemption was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee, after diversifying its industrial production to manufacture unrelated goods, remained entitled to the sales tax exemption under Clause 5 of the exemption notification.

Analysis: Clause 5 of the notification extended the exemption only where a dealer, during the period of eligibility, undertook modernisation or diversification in the new industrial unit and, as a result, produced additional principal products, by-products, waste products, additional raw material, incidental goods, or packing material connected with the original unit. The diversified products manufactured by the assessee, namely DVD boxes, television sets and sanitary napkins, were unrelated to the principal products of the industrial unit and could not be treated as additional principal products, by-products or waste products within the notification. An exemption notification must be strictly construed at the stage of eligibility, and benefit can be extended only when the assessee squarely falls within its terms.

Conclusion: The assessee was not entitled to the exemption benefit under the notification.

Final Conclusion: The appeals failed because the diversified products fell outside the scope of the exemption notification and the refusal to grant sales tax exemption was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: A claimant to exemption must strictly satisfy the eligibility conditions in the notification, and diversification into unrelated products does not attract a clause limited to additional principal products, by-products or waste products of the original industrial unit.

---