CENVAT credit appeal classification may be treated as a Central Excise matter when excise and service tax both arise.

CENVAT credit disputes are to be classified by reference to the assessee's tax profile and the nature of the credit involved. Where an assessee is engaged only in manufacture and payment of excise duty, the matter is treated as an excise dispute; where it is only a service provider, it is treated as a service tax matter. If both excise duty and service tax are involved, a CENVAT credit appeal may be registered and dealt with under Central Excise for administrative convenience. On that basis, the appeal was correctly treated as a Central Excise appeal.

---

---

Issues: Whether an appeal involving a dispute relating to CENVAT credit, where the assessee was engaged in both manufacture of excisable goods and payment of service tax, should be registered and treated as an excise appeal.

Analysis: The CENVAT credit scheme operates as a common credit pool and may arise from excise duty on inputs or capital goods, customs duty on imported goods, and service tax on input services. Where an assessee is engaged only in manufacturing and paying excise duty, a CENVAT credit dispute is appropriately treated as an excise matter. Where the assessee is only a service provider, the dispute may be treated as a service tax matter. Where both excise duty and service tax are involved, the appeal relating to CENVAT credit can be treated as an appeal under Central Excise for administrative convenience.

Conclusion: The appeal was rightly to be registered and dealt with as a Central Excise appeal.

---