Rectification power cannot be used as review; reappreciating evidence to change penalty findings exceeds statutory limits.

The Supreme Court held that rectification under section 37 of the Rajasthan Sales Tax Act is confined to correcting a mistake apparent from the record and cannot be used as a review power or to reappreciate evidence. The Board exceeded that limit by reopening concluded findings on mala fide intention, penalty, and tax liability and reaching a different conclusion on merits. The rectification order was therefore without jurisdiction, the High Court's affirming judgment was set aside, and the assessing officer's original order was restored.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Taxation Board, while exercising rectification power under section 37 of the Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1994, could reappreciate the evidence and effectively review its earlier appellate order by reopening the question of penalty and tax liability.

Analysis: The rectification power under section 37 is confined to correcting a mistake apparent from the record. It is not a power of review and does not permit a fresh appraisal of evidence or a change of conclusion on merits. The Board had initially held, on appreciation of the record, that the goods in question were different articles and restored the assessing officer's order. In the later order, it went beyond rectification and re-examined the record to hold that there was no mala fide intention and that penalty was not leviable. Such reappreciation of evidence and reversal of a concluded finding exceeded the statutory limits of section 37.

Conclusion: The rectification order was without jurisdiction and could not be sustained. The Board's later order and the High Court's affirming judgment were set aside, and the assessing officer's original order was restored.

Ratio Decidendi: A statutory power of rectification is limited to correcting an apparent mistake and cannot be used as a substitute for review or for reappreciating evidence to reach a different conclusion on merits.

---