Fixed-price liquor licences and tax collection at source: regulated L-13 dealers were treated as outside the scheme's intended reach.

Section 206C was examined in relation to L-13 liquor licence holders whose purchase and sale prices were fixed by the licensing authority. The text states that, because these licensees operated under a regulated fixed-price scheme and were not the class of buyers targeted by collection-at-source provisions aimed at tax evasion, applying tax collection at the purchase stage would be arbitrary and unrelated to their nominal profit. It further notes that the amendment to section 206C and the deletion of section 44AC did not materially alter that position. On that basis, the article records that collection of income-tax from such licensees at purchase was not permissible.

---

---

Issues: Whether income-tax could be collected at the purchase stage from L-13 liquor licence holders under section 206C of the Income-tax Act, 1961, as amended, when their sale price was fixed by the Financial Commissioner under the licence rules.

Analysis: The licence scheme showed that L-13 licensees purchased and sold country liquor at prices fixed by the authorities and did not operate in the manner contemplated by the collection-at-source provision for buyers evading tax. The amended section 206C was materially similar in substance to the earlier statutory arrangement considered in prior binding precedent, and the deletion of section 44AC did not alter the essential position for L-13 licensees. On that reasoning, applying tax collection at 15 per cent plus surcharge at the purchase stage would bear no rational relation to the nominal profit available to these licensees and would be arbitrary in its application to them.

Conclusion: The collection of income-tax from L-13 licensees at the time of purchase was not permissible, and the respondents were directed not to deduct or charge such tax from them under section 206C.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a tax-collection-at-source provision is directed at buyers who can evade tax, it cannot be applied to a fixed-price, regulated class whose transaction structure makes such collection arbitrary and unrelated to real income.

---