Customs must release Bank Guarantees on time as per Settlement Commission's order

The court directed Customs Authorities to comply with the Settlement Commission's order for the release of Bank Guarantees/Bonds and cash payments by a specified deadline, with the Commissioner of Customs (Import) personally responsible for ensuring prompt compliance. Despite acknowledging delays in the petitioner's representation, the court emphasized the importance of timely execution of the Commission's decision and held the Commissioner of Customs (Import) directly accountable for fulfilling the order without imposing any costs.

---

---

Issues:
1. Compliance with the order of the Settlement Commission for release of Bank Guarantees/Bonds and cash payments.
2. Delay in complying with the Settlement Commission's order.
3. Role of Customs Authorities and Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) in the matter.
4. Responsibility of the Commissioner of Customs (Import) for ensuring compliance with the order.

Issue 1: Compliance with the order of the Settlement Commission for release of Bank Guarantees/Bonds and cash payments.
The petition sought a mandamus to various respondents, including the Union of India, Commissioner of Customs (Import), Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI), and Commissioner of Customs (Export) for the release of Bank Guarantees/Bonds and cash payments as directed by the Settlement Commission's order dated 23rd September, 2015. The Settlement Commission had ordered the release within 15 days of its decision. The respondents admitted that the petitioner's representation was delayed, but the Settlement Commission's order had to be complied with. The petitioner urged immediate compliance due to the existing delay. The court directed Customs Authorities to comply with the Settlement Commission's order by 30th December, 2015, with the Commissioner of Customs (Import) personally responsible for ensuring compliance.

Issue 2: Delay in complying with the Settlement Commission's order.
The respondents acknowledged a delay in the petitioner's representation regarding the release of Bank Guarantees/Bonds and cash payments, with differing dates provided by the parties. Despite the delay, the court emphasized the necessity of prompt compliance with the Settlement Commission's order. The court noted that the delay in compliance was a concern and directed Customs Authorities to fulfill the order by a specified deadline, holding the Commissioner of Customs (Import) personally accountable for the execution.

Issue 3: Role of Customs Authorities and Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) in the matter.
The counsels representing Customs Authorities and DRI confirmed that no additional representation was needed to comply with the Settlement Commission's order. They admitted the obligation to adhere to the Commission's decision and requested a two-week extension for compliance. The court found the conduct of the Union of India, seeking time to file a counter affidavit, dilatory, stating that unnecessary delays without valid reasons were unwarranted. Consequently, the court directed Customs Authorities to fulfill the Settlement Commission's order by a specified date, emphasizing the importance of timely compliance.

Issue 4: Responsibility of the Commissioner of Customs (Import) for ensuring compliance with the order.
The court specifically held the person occupying the Office of the Commissioner of Customs (Import) personally responsible for ensuring compliance with the Settlement Commission's order regarding the release of Bank Guarantees/Bonds and cash payments. By assigning personal responsibility to the Commissioner, the court aimed to ensure prompt and effective execution of the Commission's decision without further delays. No costs were imposed in the disposition of the petition, highlighting the court's focus on the timely and efficient resolution of the matter.

This detailed analysis of the judgment highlights the issues addressed by the court, the parties involved, and the specific directives issued for compliance with the Settlement Commission's order.

---