Returnable container deposits are not sale consideration where forfeiture is only damages for non-return.

A security deposit taken for returnable gas cylinders, where the terms made the cylinders returnable and provided forfeiture only on non-return, was held not to be sale consideration. The amount secured return of the containers and did not reflect an intention to transfer property for valuable consideration; the transaction was a bailment, and forfeiture operated as damages for non-return rather than price. As the statutory elements of sale, sale price and turnover under the Central Sales Tax Act were not satisfied, the tax levy on the forfeited deposit was unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the security amount taken for returnable gas cylinders, when forfeited on non-return of the cylinders, constituted sale consideration and was liable to tax.

Analysis: The security voucher expressly made the cylinders returnable and provided for forfeiture on failure to return them, showing that the amount was taken to secure return and not as consideration for transfer of property in the cylinders. The transaction was one of bailment, and the forfeited amount represented damages for non-return rather than price. The statutory definitions of sale, sale price and turnover under the Central Sales Tax Act required a transfer of property for valuable consideration, which was absent on these facts. The principle applied in the governing precedent on returnable containers supported the conclusion that, where there is no intention to sell the containers and the deposit is merely a safeguard, forfeiture of the deposit does not become sale price.

Conclusion: The forfeited security amount was not sale consideration and was not liable to tax.

Final Conclusion: The revision succeeded and the tax levy on the forfeited cylinder security was unsustainable.

Ratio Decidendi: A deposit taken for returnable containers, where the terms clearly establish returnability and no intention to sell the containers exists, is part of a bailment arrangement and any forfeiture for non-return is damages, not sale price.

---