Packing charges deductible from turnover only within the rule-based limit, with the earlier precedent defeating the assessee's claim.

Packing charges were considered deductible from taxable turnover only to the extent permitted by the Karnataka Sales Tax Rules, 1957, specifically Rule 6(4)(ff). The article notes that the issue was governed by an earlier decision on the same question, under which the assessee's claim could not succeed. The stated result is that the claim for deduction was rejected and the appeals failed, leaving the revenue assessment undisturbed.

---

---

Issues: Whether packing charges were deductible from taxable turnover under the Karnataka Sales Tax Rules, 1957.

Analysis: The appeals were governed by the earlier decision on the same question, under which the claim relating to packing charges could not succeed. Rule 6(4)(ff) of the Karnataka Sales Tax Rules, 1957 was noticed as an additional ground supporting exclusion of packing charges only in the manner provided by the rule.

Conclusion: The claim of the assessee was rejected and the appeals failed.

Final Conclusion: The judgment confirms the dismissal of the appeals and leaves the revenue's assessment undisturbed.

Ratio Decidendi: Packing charges are deductible from taxable turnover only to the extent permitted by the specific turnover-deduction rule, and a contrary claim cannot succeed where the issue is already covered by binding precedent.

---