Tax treatment of agricultural receipts in liquidation: liquidator sales treated as trading activity and taxed at company rate.

Sale proceeds of casuarina trees and charcoal realised by the liquidator were held to partake of the company's ordinary agricultural trading activity because the post commencement sales followed the same pattern as pre liquidation transactions; the court applied the distinction between mere realisation and trading and found no factual indicators of isolated realisations. Consequently, receipts in liquidation were taxable as agricultural income in the same manner as prior company receipts under the Madras Agricultural Income tax Act, and the Tribunal's assessment at the maximum company rate was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether the sale proceeds of casuarina trees and charcoal realised by the liquidator after the commencement of liquidation are liable to assessment as agricultural income at the maximum company rate under the Madras Agricultural Income-tax Act, V of 1955.

Analysis: The Court examined whether the liquidator's sales were mere realisation of assets in winding up or a continuation of the company's ordinary trading activity. Reliance was placed on authorities distinguishing mere realisation from trading and on the principle that whether sales during liquidation constitute trading depends on the facts and the pattern of the transactions. The sales in question followed the same pattern as pre-liquidation sales, with no evidence of slump or clear indicators of purely realisation sales; subsequent disposal of land did not render earlier sales into realisations. Given these factual findings, the sales were held to partake of the company's ordinary activity rather than being isolated realisations.

Conclusion: The Tribunal's assessment treating the liquidator's receipts as taxable in the same manner as the company's ordinary agricultural receipts (i.e., at the maximum company rate) is upheld; the revision is dismissed and the Tribunal's order requires no interference.

---