Transfer of right to use goods test: bus-hire contracts remained service agreements because the contractor kept effective control.

Bus-hire arrangements for transport services did not amount to a transfer of the right to use goods under Section 3-F of the U.P. Trade Tax Act because the contractor retained effective control of the vehicles. The agreements required the contractor to bear fuel, maintenance, taxes, insurance, permits, staffing, accident risk, and liability for defaults, while the contracting institutions could use the buses only for specified transport services and not for other purposes. Applying the test that taxable transfer requires legal exclusion of the transferor and effective control by the transferee, the arrangement was treated as a service contract, not a deemed sale. The tax demand was therefore not sustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the bus-hire arrangements amounted to a transfer of the right to use goods so as to attract tax under Section 3-F of the U.P. Trade Tax Act.

Analysis: The agreements showed that the buses remained under the contractor's control, while the contracting institutions only had the right to use them for specified transport services. The contractor bore fuel, maintenance, taxes, insurance, permits, staffing, accident risk, and liability for defaults, and the vehicles could not be used for other purposes by the contracting institutions. Applying the test that a taxable transfer requires effective control and exclusion of the transferor's rights, the arrangement was found to be only a service contract and not a transfer of the right to use the vehicles.

Conclusion: The arrangement was not taxable under Section 3-F, and the revision was dismissed in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The tax demand could not be sustained because the contracts did not amount to a deemed sale by transfer of the right to use the buses.

Ratio Decidendi: A contract for providing vehicles for transport services is not a transfer of the right to use goods unless the transferee obtains effective control and legal exclusion of the transferor for the period of use.

---