Partition claims in Hindu undivided family assessments require statutory enquiry and notice before status can be finally determined.

Where a Hindu undivided family claims partition or division by metes and bounds, section 30(1) of the Karnataka Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1957 requires the Agricultural Income-tax Officer to make an enquiry and, if satisfied, record an order after notice to the adult members entitled to the property. An assessment made without that enquiry and without a proper section 30(1) order is vulnerable, and a revisional authority cannot conclusively reject the partition claim or determine continued joint family status without following the statutory procedure. The legal point is that status cannot be finally determined unless the prescribed enquiry and hearing safeguards are observed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessment and revisional orders treating the assessee as a Hindu undivided family could stand without the enquiry contemplated by section 30(1) of the Karnataka Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1957, when partition or division by metes and bounds was claimed.

Analysis: Section 30(1) requires the Agricultural Income-tax Officer, when a claim of partition or maintenance division is made in respect of a Hindu undivided family hitherto assessed as undivided, to make such enquiry as he thinks fit and, if satisfied that partition or division by metes and bounds has taken place, to record an order to that effect. The proviso further contemplates notice to the adult members entitled to the property. The assessment in question was completed without such enquiry and without a proper order under section 30(1). The revisional authority was therefore justified in holding that the assessment order was unsustainable. However, the revisional authority could not itself reject the claim of partition as a device or make a conclusive finding on the continuance of joint family status without the requisite enquiry and hearing contemplated by the statute.

Conclusion: The assessment order and the revisional finding treating the assessee as a Hindu undivided family could not be sustained to that extent and were liable to be quashed, with the matter to be reconsidered after a proper enquiry under section 30(1).

Ratio Decidendi: Where partition of a Hindu undivided family is claimed, a conclusive determination of status cannot be made without the statutory enquiry under section 30(1) and notice to the adult members concerned.

---