Actual industrial use controls tax classification, so casuarina bought for paper manufacture was not exempt firewood.

Casuarina wood purchased in sized form for use as paper-manufacturing raw material was held not to qualify as firewood for exemption purposes. The Tribunal treated classification by the true nature of the transaction and the actual industrial use, rather than a broad common-parlance label, and found the exemption notification inapplicable. Purchase tax was therefore upheld. The penalty, already restricted to 50 per cent of the tax due, was also sustained because it had been moderated by the Tribunal.

---

---

Issues: Whether casuarina wood purchased and used by a paper manufacturer as raw material for production of paper was to be treated as firewood and, therefore, exempt from purchase tax under the exemption notification, and whether the penalty restricted to 50 per cent of the tax due called for interference.

Analysis: The exemption notification was intended to cover firewood ordinarily used as fuel, and classification had to be made on the basis of the true nature of the goods in the relevant transaction. The mere fact that casuarina may generally be understood in common parlance as firewood did not control the issue where the evidence showed that the assessee purchased the goods in sized form specifically for use in the paper industry as raw material. The actual user and surrounding circumstances showed that the goods were not acquired as fuel or firewood but for manufacture of paper. The penalty was also found to have already been moderated by the Tribunal.

Conclusion: The casuarina purchased for use in the paper industry was not firewood, the exemption notification was inapplicable, the purchase tax levy was upheld, and the restricted penalty was confirmed.

Final Conclusion: The revision failed in its challenge to the tax levy and the consequential penalty order remained undisturbed, leaving the Revenue's assessment substantially intact.

Ratio Decidendi: Where goods are purchased with clear evidence of a specific industrial use, their classification for tax exemption purposes must be determined by that actual use and commercial understanding in the transaction, not by a general or abstract description of the article.

---