Plastic goods classification in taxing entries covers HDPE bags, confirming liability under the relevant schedule entry.

HDPE bags were held to fall within entry 16-A(iii) of the Second Schedule to the Entry Tax Act, 1979 because that entry covers plastic films, bottles, pots, jars, bags and cushioning material, and the word "bags" must be read in the context of the plastic genus. Polythene and HDPE are understood in common and commercial parlance as plastic products, so the material and market understanding brought the goods within the entry. The earlier cloth-bag ruling was distinguished as it concerned a different material and a narrower entry. A later reference to polyethylene and related films was treated as clarificatory, confirming that such goods were always within the taxing provision and liable to entry tax.

---

---

Issues: Whether HDPE bags fall within entry 16-A(iii) of the Second Schedule to the Entry Tax Act, 1979 so as to attract entry tax.

Analysis: Entry 16-A specifically mentions paper bags in clause (i) and gunny bags in clause (v), while clause (iii) refers to plastic films, bottles, pots, jars, bags and cushioning material. The expression "bags" in clause (iii) is to be read in the context of plastic items grouped in that entry. HDPE bags are polythene products and polythene is a plastic product in common and commercial parlance. The earlier decision concerning cloth bags was distinguishable because it dealt with a different material and a specifically limited entry. The subsequent insertion of polyvinyl chloride and polyethylene films was treated as clarificatory, since these are species of the same plastic genus.

Conclusion: HDPE bags are covered by entry 16-A(iii) of the Second Schedule to the Entry Tax Act, 1979 and are liable to entry tax.

Ratio Decidendi: In interpreting tariff or taxing entries, words describing a genus include goods commercially understood to fall within that genus, and a clarificatory amendment may confirm that such goods were always within the entry.

---