2000 (7) TMI 925 - AT - VAT and Sales Tax

Appellate Tribunal upholds tax liability on sale of empty tins under Tamil Nadu Sales Tax Act

Giri and Company Versus Commercial Tax Officer, Kothawalchavadi Assessment Circle, Madras

The Appellate Tribunal Tamil Nadu Taxation Special Tribunal upheld the tax liability on the sale of empty tins for the year 1990-91 under the Tamil Nadu ... - Issues:1. Assessment of taxable turnover for the year 1990-91 under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.2. Claim of exemption on second sales of edible oils and empty tins.3. Interpretation of section 3(7) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 regarding taxation of containers or packing materials.4. Application of tax on the sale of empty tins and second sales exemption.Analysis:1. The case involved the assessment of the taxable turnover for the year 1990-91 under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959. The assessees, who were dealers in ghee, butter, vanaspathi, and edible oil, reported their total and taxable turnover. The assessing authority found that the sale of empty tins was not eligible for exemption, leading to objections from the assessee regarding the taxation on the sale of empty tins.2. The claim of exemption on second sales of edible oils and empty tins was a crucial issue in the case. The assessees argued that the empty tins sold by them had already suffered single-point tax earlier and should be eligible for second sales exemption. However, the objections were rejected based on the interpretation of section 3(7) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, which disallowed the claimed exemption.3. The interpretation of section 3(7) of the Act regarding the taxation of containers or packing materials was extensively discussed. The Tribunal analyzed previous judgments and legal provisions to determine the applicability of tax on containers or packing materials at the same rate as the goods themselves. The Tribunal rejected the argument that packing materials were taxed under section 3(7) and emphasized that the levy was on the goods themselves.4. The judgment affirmed the lower authorities' decision that the sale of empty tins was exigible to tax unless concrete proof was provided that such tins had independently suffered tax earlier. The Tribunal referenced a relevant case to support its decision and concluded that the claim of second sales exemption was rightly rejected. Consequently, the tax revision case was dismissed, upholding the tax liability on the sale of empty tins.This detailed analysis provides insights into the assessment, exemption claims, statutory interpretations, and tax liability issues addressed in the legal judgment by the Appellate Tribunal Tamil Nadu Taxation Special Tribunal.