Dominant purpose test: balloons treated as children's toys and exempt under the Fifth Schedule entry

Balloons sold by the assessee were treated as children's toys for purposes of entry 47 of the Fifth Schedule to the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957. The court applied the principle that where a commodity may fit more than one description, classification depends on the entry that truly applies, and the dominant purpose of the goods prevails over incidental use. As balloons are primarily used by children as toys and only incidentally for decoration, balloons costing not more than Rs. 20 per item fell within the exempt schedule entry and were not taxable as general goods under the charging provision.

---

---

Issues: Whether balloons sold by the assessee were childrens' toys falling under entry 47 of the Fifth Schedule to the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957, and therefore entitled to exemption from tax.

Analysis: Section 5(1) of the Act is the general charging provision, while goods specifically covered by the Fifth Schedule are exempt. A commodity may answer more than one description, and in such cases its classification depends on the entry which truly applies. Balloons are primarily used by children as toys, and their occasional decorative use is only incidental. The decisive consideration is the dominant purpose of the goods, not a secondary or occasional use. On that basis, balloons costing not more than Rs. 20 per item fall within entry 47 as childrens' toys.

Conclusion: The issue was decided in favour of the assessee. Balloons were held to be childrens' toys under entry 47 of the Fifth Schedule and not taxable as general goods under section 5(1).

---