Pre-deposit conditions in tax appeals require a recorded finding of financial incapacity before insisting on further deposit.

The appellate authority under section 39(5) of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973 could insist on pre-deposit only after being satisfied, on the material placed before it, that the assessee was unable to pay the assessed tax, penalty or interest, and after recording a finding on that financial incapacity. The High Court found that the impugned order contained no such application of mind or finding on the assessee's financial position. The direction to deposit fifty per cent of the balance demand was therefore unsustainable and the relief was granted in favour of the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellate authority could insist on deposit of fifty per cent of the balance tax demand for entertaining the appeal without recording a finding on the assessee's inability to pay, as required by the proviso to section 39(5) of the Haryana General Sales Tax Act, 1973.

Analysis: Section 39(5) permits an appeal to be entertained without prior deposit only when the appellate authority is satisfied, on the material placed before it, that the assessee is unable to pay the assessed tax, penalty or interest. The authority must apply its mind to the relevant material and record a finding on financial incapacity. The impugned order did not advert to these requirements and contained no finding on the petitioner's financial position. In these circumstances, the direction to deposit fifty per cent of the balance amount could not be sustained.

Conclusion: The order insisting on further deposit was invalid and the relief was granted in favour of the assessee.

---