Wealth-tax land valuation dispute treated as a factual issue; valuation upheld and no reference was warranted.

Valuation of land for wealth-tax purposes was treated as a factual matter where the land stood exempted from the Urban Land Ceiling Act and a 10 per cent deduction had been allowed for restriction on alienation. The Tribunal upheld the wealth-tax valuation on the basis that compensation principles under the ceiling law did not apply to exempt land, and accepted the deduction for the imposed alienation restriction. The challenge was held to raise no error in valuation principles, being a pure question of fact, so no reference was warranted and the petition was dismissed.

---

---

Issues: Whether a reference was required on the question relating to valuation of land for wealth-tax purposes, particularly where the land stood exempted from the Urban Land Ceiling Act and a 10 per cent deduction had been allowed for restriction on alienation.

Analysis: The valuation adopted by the wealth-tax authorities was upheld by the Tribunal on the footing that land exempted from the ceiling law could not be valued by applying the compensation basis under that law. The Tribunal also took note of the Government-imposed restriction on alienation and accepted the deduction of 10 per cent. The challenge was held to concern valuation on established facts, and no error in the valuation principles was shown.

Conclusion: The question raised was held to be a pure question of fact and no reference was warranted; the petition was dismissed.

---