Tax holiday exemption runs from first sale and covers turnover tax, barring refusal of declaration forms during the holiday period.

A tax holiday notification under the West Bengal Sales Tax Act was construed to operate from the date of first sale of the notified commodity, not from the date of application, so the eligibility certificate had to be amended accordingly. The exemption language that "no tax shall be payable" during the holiday was treated as wide enough to include turnover tax, because a narrower reading would defeat the relief intended by the notification. On that basis, authorities could not withhold declaration forms for non-payment of turnover tax, and any amount collected under protest was refundable or adjustable during the currency of the certificate.

---

---

Issues: (i) whether the eligibility certificate granting exemption under the tax holiday notification should operate from the date of first sale of the notified commodity or only from the date of application; and (ii) whether the exemption from payment of tax under the notification covered turnover tax, so as to prevent withholding of declaration forms for non-payment of turnover tax.

Issue (i): Whether the eligibility certificate granting exemption under the tax holiday notification should operate from the date of first sale of the notified commodity or only from the date of application.

Analysis: The notification under section 4AA of the West Bengal Sales Tax Act, 1954 provided that the tax holiday would run for a specified period from the date of first sale of the manufactured notified commodity. The admitted first sale was on 16 November 1985, and the authorities accepted that the certificate had been made effective only from the later date of application. On the construction of the notification, the date of first sale was the triggering point for the exemption period.

Conclusion: The eligibility certificate had to be amended to make the exemption effective from 16 November 1985.

Issue (ii): Whether the exemption from payment of tax under the notification covered turnover tax, so as to prevent withholding of declaration forms for non-payment of turnover tax.

Analysis: The notification stated that no tax shall be payable during the tax holiday. The Court treated the expression as wide enough to cover turnover tax as well, because the exemption would otherwise be rendered illusory for the assessee during the holiday period. In the absence of tax due, rule 27AA(2)(c) of the Bengal Sales Tax Rules, 1941 could not be invoked to deny declaration forms. The withholding of declaration forms on the ground of non-payment of turnover tax was therefore unsustainable, and the amount collected under protest was liable to be refunded or adjusted.

Conclusion: The exemption covered turnover tax, the authorities could not refuse declaration forms for non-payment of that tax, and the assessee was not liable to pay turnover tax during the currency of the eligibility certificate.

Final Conclusion: The writ petition succeeded, the exemption was directed to run from the date of first sale, and the assessee was granted consequential relief including issuance of declaration forms and refund or adjustment of the amount collected under protest.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a tax holiday notification provides that no tax shall be payable from the date of first sale, the exemption must be given full effect according to that triggering date and extends to all tax liability under the enactment for the holiday period, including turnover tax, so long as the eligibility certificate remains operative.

---