Bottle deposit retained as sale price, while separately recovered export pass fee was excluded from taxable turnover.

An unrefunded amount described as a security deposit on beer bottles was treated as part of the sale consideration where no contractual time-limit for return or true bailment was shown, and the retained portion was therefore liable to sales tax. A separately recovered export pass fee charged from out-of-State customers was excluded from taxable turnover because the dealer's liability for that fee was not proved and the department failed to establish its inclusion in sale consideration. The subject matter thus distinguishes retained bottle deposits, which form part of price, from a statutory fee that is deductible when its taxable character is not established.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the unrefunded portion of the security deposit collected on beer bottles formed part of the sale price and was liable to sales tax; (ii) whether the export pass fee realised from outstation customers was includible in the taxable turnover.

Issue (i): Whether the unrefunded portion of the security deposit collected on beer bottles formed part of the sale price and was liable to sales tax.

Analysis: The transaction showed a separate charge for beer and a separate amount described as deposit on bottles, but there was no contractual stipulation fixing any time-limit for return of the bottles or establishing a true bailment. The deposit was not treated as an actionable claim, and the nature of the arrangement indicated that the amount kept as security functioned as part of the commercial transaction of sale. On the facts, the amounts remaining with the seller after refund, if any, represented the price of the bottles retained by the assessee.

Conclusion: The unrefunded security deposit formed part of the sale price of the bottles and was liable to sales tax, against the assessee.

Issue (ii): Whether the export pass fee realised from outstation customers was includible in the taxable turnover.

Analysis: The fee had been deposited in advance under the relevant Government notification and recovered separately from outside-State purchasers. In the absence of reliable evidence establishing that the fee was the dealer's liability and in view of the deduction already allowed for amounts actually refunded, the department failed to establish that the sum recovered as export pass fee formed part of the taxable turnover.

Conclusion: The export pass fee was deductible from the turnover and the levy on that amount was not justified, in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The application succeeded in part. The export pass fee was excluded from turnover, while the forfeited portion of the bottle deposit remained taxable as sale price of the bottles.

Ratio Decidendi: An amount collected as a so-called security deposit on bottles, where no obligation or time-limit for return is shown, is part of the consideration for the sale to the extent it is retained by the dealer after refund; a separately recovered statutory fee is deductible only if its inclusion in sale consideration is not established and the dealer's liability is not proved.

---