Railway sale of coal-ash treated as business activity, making the turnover taxable under sales tax law.

Disposal of coal-ash and similar unserviceable railway material by auction or contract was treated as incidental or ancillary to the Railways' trade, so the activity constituted business under the Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1954 and brought the Railways within the definition of a dealer for that turnover. The reference on penalty and prior realization of tax was not answered because those questions were held incompetent. The ruling follows earlier decisions treating such sales as part of a railway's business activity and therefore taxable as sales made in the course of business.

---

---

Issues: Whether the disposal of coal-ash by the Railways through auction or contract was incidental or ancillary to its trade so as to constitute business and render it liable as a dealer under the Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1954.

Analysis: The reference on the first question was decided by applying the earlier rulings that the sale of coal-ash and similar unserviceable material by a railway is part of its business activity. On that footing, such sale falls within the statutory concept of business and the railway answers the description of a dealer in relation to that turnover. The questions relating to penalty and prior realization of tax were not answered because the reference on those points was held incompetent.

Conclusion: The disposal of coal-ash through auction or contract was held to be incidental or ancillary to the trade of the Railways, and the railway was held liable to sales tax on such sales.

---