Electric motors taxed as electrical goods, with industrial-use motors qualifying for concessional machinery treatment.

Electric motors were held exempt under entry 17 of the Third Schedule only if they were within the 3 to 7.5 h.p. range; the qualifying words were read as limiting electric motors generally, so larger motors were not exempt. Electric motors were also treated as electrical goods under entry 15 of the First Schedule. However, when a motor was sold for industrial use, it fell within entry 27 of the notification dated 21 October 1975 as part of industrial machinery and plant, attracting the concessional rate; otherwise, the general rate for electrical goods applied.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether electric motors other than 3 to 7.5 h.p. fall within entry 17 of the Third Schedule of the Delhi Sales Tax Act, 1975 and are exempt from sales tax; (ii) Whether such electric motors are covered by entry 15 of the First Schedule, or by entry 27 of the notification dated 21st October, 1975 as parts of industrial machinery and plant.

Issue (i): Whether electric motors other than 3 to 7.5 h.p. fall within entry 17 of the Third Schedule of the Delhi Sales Tax Act, 1975 and are exempt from sales tax.

Analysis: Entry 17 was construed as exempting only electric motors of 3 to 7.5 h.p. The words "including monoblock pump-sets" were treated as clarificatory, and the horse-power limitation was held to qualify electric motors, not merely monoblock pump-sets. The exemption was read as intended for the kind of motors commonly used for agricultural pumping, and not for all electric motors irrespective of rating.

Conclusion: Electric motors other than 3 to 7.5 h.p. do not fall within entry 17 and are not exempt under that entry.

Issue (ii): Whether such electric motors are covered by entry 15 of the First Schedule, or by entry 27 of the notification dated 21st October, 1975 as parts of industrial machinery and plant.

Analysis: Electric motors were held to be electrical goods within entry 15 of the First Schedule. However, where a 15 h.p. motor was sold for industrial use, it was further treated as part of industrial machinery and plant under entry 27 of the notification dated 21st October, 1975, because its functional use in industry brought it within that lower-rate category. The rate of 5 per cent was therefore applicable only when the motor was meant for industrial use; otherwise the general 10 per cent rate for electrical goods applied.

Conclusion: Electric motors are covered by entry 15 of the First Schedule unless used for industrial purposes, in which event they fall under entry 27 of the notification dated 21st October, 1975.

Final Conclusion: The references were answered by holding that only electric motors of 3 to 7.5 h.p. are exempt, that larger motors are ordinarily taxable as electrical goods, and that motors intended for industrial use attract the concessional industrial-machinery rate.

---