Sugar-candy taxable as a separate commodity when expressly listed in the sales tax schedule

Sugar-candy was treated as a distinct commercial commodity from sugar for sales tax purposes because it was separately included in the taxable schedule, while sugar remained exempt. The prior view that sugar-candy falls within sugar was distinguished on the basis that it did not address a statute that specifically names sugar-candy as taxable. Applying the common parlance and legislative classification approach, the Court recognised the legislature's power to tax separate goods even if one is manufactured from another. The writ challenge failed and the assessments were sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether sugar-candy was taxable under the Orissa Sales Tax Act notwithstanding the exemption available to sugar and the definition of sugar in the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944.

Analysis: Sugar-candy had been separately brought into the list of goods subject to sales tax during the relevant period, while sugar remained in the exempted list. The prior decision treating sugar-candy as falling within sugar was distinguished because it had not considered a situation where sugar-candy itself was separately specified as a taxable commodity. The Court applied the principle that, for sales tax, the legislature may classify and tax distinct commercial commodities separately, even if one is produced from the other. Sugar-candy was treated in common parlance and in the statutory scheme as a commodity different from sugar, and its separate inclusion in the taxable list showed legislative intent to subject it to tax.

Conclusion: Sugar-candy was held liable to sales tax under the relevant entry in List C, and the challenge to the assessments failed.

Final Conclusion: The writ petition was rejected because the taxable entry validly covered sugar-candy as a separate commercial commodity distinct from exempt sugar.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a taxing statute separately specifies a commodity in the taxable schedule, that commodity is chargeable to sales tax as a distinct commercial item even if it is manufactured from a substance that is itself exempt.

---