Prima facie case for duty waiver, no excise liability on welding, cutting/bending - relief granted

The applicants established a prima facie case for a total waiver of pre-deposit of duty, interest, and penalty, resulting in the stay of recovery. The welding activity for APS units and cutting/bending of sheets for Spans and Floor Forms did not amount to manufacture, thus no excise duty liability was found. However, the creation of Props through threading, drilling, and fixing metal plates constituted manufacture, but due to the value falling under the SSI exemption, the applicants were eligible for relief.

---

---

Issues involved: Application for waiver of pre-deposit of duty of Rs. 48,52,976/- along with interest and penalty arising from the manufacture of APS units, Props, Spans, and floor forms falling under CET sub-heading 7308 40 00 as equipment for scaffolding for the period 2004-05 to 2006-07.

Manufacture of APS units: The welding activity of verticals and horizontals with socket pipe/clamp does not amount to manufacture, hence no duty demand is justified.

Manufacture of Spans: Cutting and bending of sheets into 'C' sections do not transform the sheets into a new excisable commodity, therefore no excise duty liability arises.

Manufacture of Floor Forms: Cutting and knotching of HR sheets to create floor forms do not result in a new excisable commodity, hence no duty liability is established.

Manufacture of Props: Threading, drilling, and fixing of metal plates on pipes to create props for supporting RCC beams constitutes manufacture, resulting in a new excisable commodity falling under the heading adopted by the Commissioner. However, the value of props being approximately Rs. 5 lakhs, the applicants are eligible for the benefit of SSI exemption.

Conclusion: A prima facie case has been established by the applicants for total waiver of pre-deposit of duty, interest, and penalty, leading to the stay of recovery.

---