Consequential penalty cannot survive when the foundational assessment order is set aside and no independent basis remains.

Penalty orders that are merely consequential to an assessment cannot survive once the foundational assessment is set aside in appeal. Because the penalties in issue depended entirely on the assessment proceedings and no independent legal basis survived, the orders treating the returns as incorrect and levying penalty for non-payment of assessed tax could not stand. The HC therefore held that the penalty orders were liable to be quashed, and the challenge succeeded for the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether penalty orders imposed under the sales tax law could survive after the basic assessment order, on which they were founded, had been set aside in appeal.

Analysis: The penalty orders were traced to the assessment proceedings and were not independent of the assessment order. Once the foundational assessment order was set aside, the basis for treating the returns as incorrect or for levying penalty for non-payment of the assessed tax no longer survived. In such a situation, the penalty imposed as a consequence of the assessment could not stand on its own.

Conclusion: The penalty orders could not survive and were liable to be quashed; the challenge succeeded in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: A penalty that is consequential upon an assessment order falls when the assessment order itself is set aside, unless some independent basis for the penalty survives in law.

---