Taxable turnover in sales tax: diesel and scrap included, but fertilisers and gunny bags excluded on agency and delivery-use grounds.

Supply of diesel to hired lorries was treated as taxable turnover because the contractors were under no obligation to take diesel, the supply came from the assessee's own bunk, and the transfer satisfied the statutory notion of sale. Supply of chemical fertilisers to shareholder-members was not treated as a sale, because the co-operative society's bye-laws showed that procurement and supply were part of its objects and it acted as agent for members. Sale of scrap and by-products was includible in turnover because it was regular, continuous and incidental to the main business. The value of gunny bags used for delivery of sugar was excluded, as no express or implied sale of the bags was proved and they were only the vehicle for transport.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the supply of diesel oil to hired lorries formed part of the assessee's taxable turnover; (ii) Whether the supply of chemical fertilisers to shareholders constituted a sale liable to be included in the turnover; (iii) Whether the sale of scrap and by-products was includible in the turnover as part of the assessee's business; and (iv) Whether the value of gunny bags used for delivery of sugar was liable to be included in the turnover.

Issue (i): Whether the supply of diesel oil to hired lorries formed part of the assessee's taxable turnover.

Analysis: The lorry contractors were under no contractual obligation to receive diesel from the assessee, and the diesel was voluntarily supplied from the assessee's own bunk. The supply was not shown to be part of any service contract or composite arrangement excluding sale. The transfer of diesel to the contractors therefore answered the statutory notion of sale and was properly brought to tax.

Conclusion: The inclusion of the turnover relating to diesel oil was upheld and the assessee failed on this issue.

Issue (ii): Whether the supply of chemical fertilisers to shareholders constituted a sale liable to be included in the turnover.

Analysis: The bye-laws of the co-operative society showed that procurement and supply of fertilisers to members was one of the very objects for which the society was formed. In that setting, the society acted only as an agent for its members in procuring and supplying fertilisers, and the supply was not a sale in the commercial sense. The statutory definition of sale could not be applied mechanically to treat every supply to members as a taxable sale where the legal relationship was one of agency.

Conclusion: The inclusion of the value of chemical fertilisers in the assessable turnover was rejected and this issue was decided in favour of the assessee.

Issue (iii): Whether the sale of scrap and by-products was includible in the turnover as part of the assessee's business.

Analysis: The sale of scrap, empty barrels, burnt lime and bagasse was found to be regular, continuous and incidental to the main business of the assessee. Such transactions were not casual or isolated, and the reasoning supporting inclusion was consistent with the governing sales tax principles applied to ancillary trading activity.

Conclusion: The inclusion of the turnover from scrap and by-products was upheld and the assessee failed on this issue.

Issue (iv): Whether the value of gunny bags used for delivery of sugar was liable to be included in the turnover.

Analysis: There was no express contract for sale of gunny bags, and on the facts the bags were only the convenient and cheap vehicle for delivery and transport of sugar. An implied agreement to sell the gunny bags could not be inferred merely because tax had been charged on their value. The legal character of the transaction had to be determined by the real bargain, not by the manner in which invoices were prepared or tax was collected.

Conclusion: The inclusion of the value of the gunny bags was disallowed and this issue was decided in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The tax revisions succeeded only in part, with relief granted on the fertiliser and gunny bag components while the remaining turnover inclusions were sustained.

Ratio Decidendi: For sales tax purposes, a supply to members is not automatically a sale where the society acts as their agent under its bye-laws, and an implied sale of packing materials cannot be inferred when they function only as the convenient vehicle of delivery rather than the subject of the bargain.

---