Motor vehicle spare parts classification: a tube valve used only as a replacement part falls within the specific tax entry.

A motor tube valve with checknut, used solely as a replacement part in motor vehicle tubes, fell within entry 42B of Schedule C rather than the residuary entry 22 of Schedule E. The court held that the entry was wide enough to cover articles adapted for use as parts and accessories of specified motor vehicles, including items that required vulcanising or other fitment before use. Because the valve had no ordinary use other than as a motor vehicle part or accessory, the exclusion clause did not apply. The item was therefore taxable under the specific entry.

---

---

Issues: Whether a motor tube valve with checknut, used only as a replacement valve in motor vehicle tubes, fell under specific entry 42B of Schedule C to the Bombay Sales Tax Act, 1959, or under residuary entry 22 of Schedule E.

Analysis: Entry 42B covered not only component parts of specified motor vehicles but also other articles, including tyres, tubes and batteries, if they were adapted for use as parts and accessories of such vehicles and were not ordinarily used otherwise. The valve in question was found to be used only as a replaceable part of the motor tube in motor vehicles. The fact that it required vulcanising or fitment did not take it outside the entry, because the statutory language extended to articles capable of use as spare parts after adjustment or adaptation. The exclusion clause was not attracted since the article had no ordinary use other than as a motor vehicle part or accessory.

Conclusion: The article was covered by entry 42B of Schedule C and not by residuary entry 22 of Schedule E.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a tax entry covers articles adapted for use as parts and accessories of specified motor vehicles, an item used solely as a replacement spare part remains within the entry even if some fitment or adaptation is required before use.

---