Binding effect of higher court ruling defeats penalty demand, while prepaid interest is adjusted as already recorded.

Penalty on the disputed clearances could not be sustained because the higher court had already negatived the Revenue's challenge in connected proceedings, and the Tribunal was bound to follow that ruling; the assessee therefore succeeded on the penalty issue. Interest already deposited was not open to fresh contest on the same footing and was to be adjusted as recorded in the order. The matter accordingly resulted in relief from penalty, with the pre-paid interest treated as appropriately appropriated.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether penalty was leviable in respect of the clearances in question. (ii) Whether the interest already paid was liable to be appropriated.

Issue (i): Whether penalty was leviable in respect of the clearances in question.

Analysis: The question of penalty had already been answered against the Revenue by the High Court in the connected proceedings, and the matter before the Tribunal was to be decided in conformity with that ruling. Once the higher court had negatived the Revenue's challenge on penalty, no further order confirming penalty could be sustained.

Conclusion: Penalty was not leviable and the assessee succeeded on this issue.

Issue (ii): Whether the interest already paid was liable to be appropriated.

Analysis: The interest aspect was not available for fresh adjudication on the same footing as penalty. The order records that interest had already been deposited by the assessee and that the amount was not being contested further, so the payment was to be adjusted accordingly.

Conclusion: The interest already paid was liable to be appropriated.

Final Conclusion: The dispute ended with relief to the assessee on penalty, while the interest paid stood adjusted in accordance with the order.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the higher court has negatived the Revenue's challenge on penalty, the penal demand cannot be sustained, and any interest already paid may be treated as appropriately adjusted when not further contested.

---