Fibre optic endoscope exemption denied for a composite surgical system; pre-deposit waiver refused absent financial hardship.

The exemption for fibre optic endoscopes was held inapplicable to a composite Da Vinci surgical system, because the imported goods consisted of multiple integrated components and the endoscope was only one part of the complete system. Product literature and surrounding evidence supported classification of the item as a surgical system rather than a standalone endoscope, and the altered description did not extend the notification benefit. No financial hardship was shown, so waiver of pre-deposit was refused and deposit of duty was directed, with waiver of penalties to follow upon deposit during the appeal.

---

---

Issues: Whether the imported Da Vinci surgical system was eligible for exemption as a fibre optic endoscope under Notification No. 21/2002-Cus dated 01.03.2002, and consequently whether waiver of pre-deposit of duty and penalties should be granted.

Analysis: The imported equipment was found, on the product literature and surrounding evidence, to be a composite Da Vinci surgical system comprising multiple components such as a surgical console, surgical arm cart, vision system, endowrist instruments, and a high resolution 3-D endoscope. The endoscope was only one part of the entire system and the description of the goods had been altered at the applicant's instance. The exemption claimed was specific to fibre optic endoscopes, not to a complete surgical system containing an endoscope as one component. No financial hardship was shown to justify waiver of pre-deposit.

Conclusion: The benefit of the notification was not available to the imported system, and the request for waiver of pre-deposit was rejected. The applicant was directed to deposit the duty amount, with waiver of penalties to follow upon such deposit during the pendency of the appeal.

---