Bad debt write-off, BSE membership depreciation and timing of TDS on salary under income-tax rules clarified.

Bad debt is allowable once it is actually written off in the books and the section 36(2) conditions are satisfied, with any later recovery taxable under section 41. Depreciation is available on a Bombay Stock Exchange membership card where the asset has already been treated as depreciable on the same facts. Loss on sale of securities falls within the anti-avoidance rule in section 94(7) where the amended dividend-stripping provision applies. Salary and perquisite payments to an expatriate employee are governed by tax deduction at payment under section 192, and are not disallowed under section 40(a)(iii) merely because tax was not deducted at accrual or credit. Interest under section 234D does not apply to refunds granted before 1-6-2003.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the bad debts written off were allowable where the amounts had been written off in the books and the conditions of section 36(2) were satisfied; (ii) whether depreciation was allowable on the Bombay Stock Exchange membership card; (iii) whether loss on sale of securities was disallowable under section 94(7); (iv) whether salary and perquisite payments to an expatriate employee were hit by section 40(a)(iii) for want of deduction of tax at source at the stage of accrual or credit; and (v) whether interest under section 234D could be charged for refund granted prior to 1-6-2003.

Issue (i): Whether the bad debts written off were allowable where the amounts had been written off in the books and the conditions of section 36(2) were satisfied.

Analysis: The debts had been actually written off as irrecoverable in the books of account. The post-amendment position under section 36(1)(vii) requires write-off in the accounts and satisfaction of the conditions in section 36(2), with any later recovery being taxable under section 41. On those facts, the disallowance of bad debt could not be sustained.

Conclusion: The claim for bad debt was allowable and the assessee succeeded on this issue.

Issue (ii): Whether depreciation was allowable on the Bombay Stock Exchange membership card.

Analysis: The membership card had already been treated as an eligible depreciable asset in the assessee's own case for the preceding year, following the same legal view that supported depreciation on such membership rights. The facts for the year under appeal were identical.

Conclusion: Depreciation on the membership card was allowable and the issue was decided in favour of the assessee.

Issue (iii): Whether loss on sale of securities was disallowable under section 94(7).

Analysis: The transactions fell within the amended anti-avoidance rule for dividend stripping applicable from 1-4-2002. The loss was therefore not deductible, and the alternative plea for further reduction did not survive.

Conclusion: The disallowance under section 94(7) was upheld and the assessee failed on this issue.

Issue (iv): Whether salary and perquisite payments to an expatriate employee were hit by section 40(a)(iii) for want of deduction of tax at source at the stage of accrual or credit.

Analysis: Under section 192(1), tax on salary is to be deducted at the time of payment. The salary remitted outside India was subjected to deduction at the time of actual payment, and the statute did not require deduction at the stage of accrual or credit. The perquisite value also formed part of salary and was governed by the same deduction mechanism; it did not attract a separate disallowance under section 40(a)(iii).

Conclusion: The salary and perquisite disallowances were not sustainable and the issue was decided in favour of the assessee.

Issue (v): Whether interest under section 234D could be charged for refund granted prior to 1-6-2003.

Analysis: The levy of interest under section 234D was held to be inapplicable to refunds granted before the provision came into force. The interest charged on the earlier refund could not therefore stand.

Conclusion: The interest levy under section 234D was deleted and the assessee succeeded on this issue.

Final Conclusion: The appeals were disposed of by sustaining the disallowance of the dividend-stripping loss while granting relief on bad debts, depreciation on the BSE membership card, salary and perquisite disallowance relating to the expatriate employee, and interest under section 234D.

Ratio Decidendi: A debt is allowable as a bad debt once it is written off in the books and the statutory conditions are met; salary tax deduction under section 192 operates at actual payment and not at mere accrual for section 40(a)(iii); and a later anti-avoidance or interest provision cannot be applied contrary to its temporal operation.

---