Long-term use exemption for infusion sets turns on functional duration, not repeated use or disposability.

Infusion sets, scalp vein sets and BT sets were treated as eligible for exemption as "intravenous cannulae and tubing for long term use" because the decisive test was functional suitability for the required period of fluid delivery, not repeated use. Their disposable or single-use character was regarded as a hygienic feature and not inconsistent with long-term use. The lower appellate authority's reversal was set aside because it had overturned the original finding without examining the samples or giving adequate basis. Exemption was restored in favour of the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether infusion sets, scalp vein sets and BT sets were eligible for exemption as "intravenous cannulae and tubing for long term use" under the relevant exemption notification.

Analysis: The items were found to consist essentially of a cannula in the form of a needle with a tube. Earlier decisions had already treated scalp vein sets as falling within the expression "intravenous cannulae and tubing for long term use". The expression "long term use" was understood to mean that the device is capable of remaining in use for the relevant period of fluid delivery, and not that it must be repeatedly used. The disposable or one-time-use character of the items was held to be a hygienic restriction and not inconsistent with long-term use. The lower appellate authority had overturned the original finding without examining the samples and without adequate basis.

Conclusion: The items were held to be eligible for exemption under the notification, and the assessee's claim succeeded.

Final Conclusion: The impugned order was set aside and the exemption benefit was restored in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: For exemption under a notification using the expression "for long term use", the decisive test is whether the goods are designed to remain functionally usable for the required duration, and a disposable or single-use character does not by itself negate long-term use.

---