Factory-gate sales to industrial consumers in bulk are wholesale transactions, making that price the normal excise valuation benchmark.

Large-quantity clearances at the factory gate to an industrial consumer were treated as wholesale sales for excise valuation. The decisive factor was the size and nature of the consignment, so the price realised in that transaction constituted the normal price under Section 4(1)(a) of the Central Excise Act. The existence of sales to other categories of buyers did not displace that benchmark. The contrary view that no wholesale sale existed at the factory gate was rejected, and valuation on the lower stock-transfer basis was not sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether large-quantity clearances to an industrial consumer at the factory gate constituted wholesale sales for the purpose of determining normal price under Section 4(1)(a) of the Central Excise Act, and consequently whether assessable value had to be fixed on that basis rather than on the lower value adopted for stock transfers.

Analysis: The decisive factor for characterising a sale as wholesale or retail is the size of the consignment. Where an industrial consumer lifts large quantities of excisable goods at the factory gate, the transaction is a wholesale sale and the price realised in such transaction represents the normal price for valuation. The existence of other sales to different classes of buyers does not displace that position. On these facts, the price charged to the industrial consumer was the proper benchmark, and the lower appellate view that there was no wholesale sale at the factory gate could not be sustained.

Conclusion: The goods cleared to the industrial consumer were sold on a wholesale basis at the factory gate, and that price constituted the normal price for assessment under Section 4(1)(a); the contrary valuation adopted below was and was set aside.

Final Conclusion: The valuation adopted by the lower appellate authority was overturned, and the demand based on differential assessable value stood restored in substance.

Ratio Decidendi: For excise valuation, a factory-gate sale to an industrial consumer in large quantities is a wholesale transaction and the price realised in that transaction is the normal price under Section 4(1)(a), even if the assessee also makes sales to other categories of buyers.

---