Captive yarn valuation includes warping and winding costs when those processes occur before deemed removal in an integrated factory.

Where yarn is captively consumed in a composite mill, warping and winding undertaken before the deemed removal of the yarn are part of manufacture and their cost enters assessable value. The reasoning treats yarn as excisable at the spindle stage, but applies Chapter Notes 1 and 3 and Rule 49 to deem removal only immediately before fabric manufacture, so all processes completed before that point are includible. An exemption for similar processes on duty-paid yarn in another factory does not alter valuation in an integrated factory. The cost of warping and winding is therefore includible in assessable value.

---

---

Issues: Whether, in the valuation of yarn captively consumed in the manufacture of fabrics in a composite mill, the cost of warping and winding is includible in the assessable value of the yarn.

Analysis: The majority held that yarn emerges as excisable goods at the spindle stage, but under Chapter Note 1 to Chapter 52 and Chapter Note 3 to Chapter 55, warping and winding are also manufacturing processes. Rule 49 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 deems captive yarn to be removed immediately before its consumption in fabric manufacture. Since the stage of deemed removal is after the yarn has undergone warping and winding, the value for duty purposes must include the cost of those processes. The majority further held that the exemption under Notification No. 5/99-C.E. supports the conclusion that the processes may be exempt when undertaken on duty-paid yarn in another factory, but that exemption does not alter valuation where the processes are undertaken in the integrated factory before deemed removal. The reasoning adopted the principle that all processes carried out before removal from the factory form part of assessable value.

Conclusion: The cost of warping and winding is includible in the assessable value of captively consumed yarn and the Revenue's appeal fails.

Ratio Decidendi: Where excisable goods are deemed to be removed only after undergoing manufacturing processes in an integrated factory, the cost of all such processes carried out before the deemed removal is includible in assessable value, even if those processes would be exempt when performed on duty-paid goods in another factory.

---