Strict compliance with exemption conditions sustains duty demand, while penalty may be reduced on the facts.

Notification-based exemption for samples cleared for quality control was available only if the samples were packed distinctly from regular trade packing. Because that condition was not satisfied, the duty demand was sustained. The penalty was nevertheless found excessive in the circumstances, with reference to the amount earlier directed to be deposited under Section 35F of the Central Excise Act, and was reduced to Rs. 10,000. The operative principle is strict compliance with exemption conditions, while penalty may be moderated on the facts.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the duty demand on samples cleared for quality control was liable to be confirmed for non-compliance with the condition in Notification No. 171/70 requiring packing distinct from regular trade packing; (ii) whether the penalty required interference and reduction.

Issue (i): Whether the duty demand on samples cleared for quality control was liable to be confirmed for non-compliance with the condition in Notification No. 171/70 requiring packing distinct from regular trade packing.

Analysis: The exemption under Serial No. 24 of the Table to Notification No. 171/70 was available only when samples were packed in a form distinctly different from regular trade packing. The samples were not so packed, and therefore the condition attached to the exemption was not satisfied.

Conclusion: The duty demand was rightly confirmed.

Issue (ii): Whether the penalty required interference and reduction.

Analysis: The penalty was examined with reference to the amount the Tribunal had earlier directed to be deposited under Section 35F of the Central Excise Act, and the penalty was considered excessive in the circumstances.

Conclusion: The penalty was reduced to Rs. 10,000.

Final Conclusion: The demand of duty was sustained, while the penalty was scaled down, resulting in partial success for the appellant.

Ratio Decidendi: A notification-based exemption is available only on strict fulfilment of its specified condition, and where that condition is not met, the duty demand can be upheld while the penalty may be moderated on the facts.

---