Modvat credit for transformer spare parts allowed where the machinery was used in producing or processing goods during manufacture.

Spare parts of transformers used in the manufacture of final products were eligible for Modvat credit because the Explanation below Rule 57Q treated spare parts of machinery covered by sub-clause (a) as eligible inputs. The denial of credit failed since sub-clause (d) did not exclude the operation of sub-clause (a), and the transformers were used for producing or processing goods in manufacture. The spare parts therefore satisfied the statutory requirement, and the credit denial was unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether spare parts of transformers used in the manufacture of final products were entitled to Modvat credit under the Explanation below Rule 57Q of the Central Excise Rules, 1944.

Analysis: The relevant Explanation treated as eligible not only machinery and equipment used for producing or processing goods or bringing about a change in substance in the course of manufacture, but also spare parts of such machinery. The denial of credit rested on the view that the spare parts were not specifically covered by sub-clause (d), but that clause did not exclude the operation of sub-clause (a). Since the transformers were used for producing or processing goods in the manufacture of the final product, the spare parts of those transformers satisfied the statutory requirement.

Conclusion: The spare parts were eligible for Modvat credit and the denial of credit was unsustainable.

---