Customs-endorsed duty certificate accepted as valid Modvat credit document where suppression or evasion is not established.

Additional duty paid on excess imports under the DEEC scheme and certified by Customs was treated as a valid duty paying document for Modvat credit. The certificate endorsed by the Customs appraiser, read with the cash challan, was accepted as primary evidence of duty payment, and the absence of an expressly listed document in Rule 57G did not by itself exclude it. The disqualification under Rule 57E(3) applied only where suppression, misstatement or evasion was established, and on the stated facts that statutory bar was not attracted. Accordingly, the Customs-endorsed certificate remained eligible for Modvat credit.

---

---

Issues: Whether CVD paid on excess imports and evidenced by a Customs-endorsed certificate constituted a valid duty paying document for Modvat credit, and whether the disqualification under Rule 57E(3) applied.

Analysis: The dispute turned on whether the additional duty was paid in circumstances attracting the disqualification for cases involving suppression, misstatement or evasion. The payment arose from excess imports under the DEEC scheme, and the importer had approached the DGFT on its own to foreclose the licence because the export obligation could not be completed. On the documentary aspect, the certificate endorsed by the Customs appraiser, supported by cash challan payment, was treated as the primary evidence of duty payment. The absence of a specifically enumerated document in Rule 57G did not exclude such a certificate from being accepted as a duty paying document where the payment itself was duly certified by Customs.

Conclusion: The disqualification under Rule 57E(3) did not apply, and the Customs-endorsed certificate was a valid duty paying document for Modvat credit.

Ratio Decidendi: Additional duty paid on goods cleared on payment through Customs and duly certified by the competent Customs authority remains a valid duty paying document for Modvat credit unless the statutory disqualification for suppression, misstatement or evasion is established.

---